By starting from two simple building blocks, benzannulated cyclooctenones were obtained in three steps. Subsequent Grignard/aryl lithium addition to the ketone yielded the corresponding tertiary alcohols that underwent stereoselective acid-catalyzed transannular cyclization to provide a cis-fused 5/5 bicyclic indanylindane framework exclusively. Subsequent stereoselective nucleophilic addition to the indanyl cation by hydride, water, or electron-rich aromatics furnished the 4b-aryltetrahydroindano[1,2-a]indenes in good to excellent yields (up to 92%) in the trans-C9–C9a form in up to a >99:1 diastereomeric ratio.